How can a co-owner force the sale of a property?

It is becoming increasingly more common for relatives and friends to purchase real property together in order to gain entry into the property market because they would otherwise not have the financial resources to purchase the property on their own.

However, disputes can arise when one party wants to sell their share of the property but the other owners do not wish to sell or one party cannot “buy out” the other parties.

Under section 38 of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) (the Act), a co-owner may make an application to court, seeking the appointment of a statutory trustee to sell a property regardless of whether the other co-owners agree or not. This can occur when family members or friends buy real property together and then fall into dispute (please note this does not cover matrimonial property settlements which are dealt with under the Family Law Act).

If the co-owners cannot reach agreement on what to do with the property, or one co-owner cannot raise enough funds to buy out the other co-owner’s share, then you can compel the sale of the property under the Act.

The process is relatively straightforward and requires an application to the court supported by affidavit evidence and the consent of a statutory trustee. Usually statutory trustees will be solicitors or accountants who will act to sell the property.

Once appointed, the statutory trustees can sell the property either by auction or private treaty.  The statutory trustee will undertake research to determine the market value of the property and decide on the best method of sale to be utilised to gain the best price for the property at the time. A real estate agent may also be appointed to sell the property.

Once sold, any parties owed funds will be paid from the proceeds of sale (i.e. mortgagees, solicitor’s fees and real estate agent’s commission).  Any funds left over will then be divided between the co-owners in proportion of their ownership.

What happens if one co-owner is residing in the property and won’t leave?

Often in the cases of co-ownership, one owner resides at the property in question and is the party refusing to sell, given the disruption it would cause for them to vacate the property.

In the event that this party disputes the sale and refuses to vacate the property, the statutory trustee, once appointed, will obtain an order for possession of the property from the court. The statutory trustee will then serve this order on the owner residing at the property, giving them a timeframe in which the property is to be sold.

If this party still refuses to leave the property, the statutory trustee will then obtain a warrant for possession and a bailiff will remove the person from the property (and will then be left to clear their belongings before the property is placed on the market).

Can the appointment of the statutory trustee be disputed?

A section 38 application for the appointment for a statutory trustee is very difficult to oppose and usually the court will grant the appointment of the statutory trustee, which will then allow the sale of the property.

However the following grounds provide bases for opposing the appointment of a statutory trustee:

  • One of the co-owners holds the property in their capacity as a trustee as evidenced by a written trust document dealing proving the entitlement to the property.  For example, a person may remarry and hold the property on trust for their children.
  • If there is an agreement in place between the co-owners that deals with how the property is to be sold in the future.  For example, there may be an agreement giving a co-owner a first right of refusal, or requiring a certain period of time, i.e. 12 months to pass before the property can be sold (in order to allow time to raise sufficient finance to buy out the other party’s share).
  • The argument that one co-owner has exhausted their share in the property and no longer has any right to claim to have an interest in the property.  For example, is a co-owner takes out a mortgage against the property for their own benefit and then does not repay that money.
  • The equity of exoneration –  for example, a first co-owner takes out a second mortgage against the property to start a new business; the other co-owners have no interest in or benefit from the business.  The business then fails, and the first co-owner is declared a bankrupt. That co-owner’s bankruptcy trustee may seek to sell the house to pay the debt.  The remaining owners may be able to argue that only the first co-owner should bear the burden of the debt, and they should be exonerated from it.

In any case there can be no guarantee that the appointment of the statutory trustee (and subsequent sale of the property) will not go ahead. Much depends on the factual background and evidence to be presented, however these applications are almost impossible to defend.

If you are considering buying real property with others, you should give consideration to what is to happen should the relationship sour or one co-owner wants to sell. A properly drafted agreement recording the co-owners’ rights and obligations could potentially save a lot of long term difficulties.

If you require advice in respect of forcing the sale of your co-owned property, or defending a s38 Application for the appointment of a statutory trustee that has been served upon you, please contact us.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Bowen Hills Conveyancing – Brisbane Conveyancing – East Brisbane Conveyancing – Fortitude Valley Conveyancing – Herston Conveyancing – Highgate Hill Conveyancing – Kangaroo Point Conveyancing – Kelvin Grove Conveyancing – New Farm Conveyancing – Newstead Conveyancing – Paddington Conveyancing – Petrie Terrace Conveyancing  – Red Hill Conveyancing – South Brisbane Conveyancing – Spring Hill Conveyancing – Teneriffe Conveyancing – West End Conveyancing – Woolloongabba Conveyancing
Albion Conveyancing – Alderley Conveyancing – Ascot Conveyancing – Aspley Conveyancing – Bald Hills Conveyancing – Banyo Conveyancing – Boondall Conveyancing – Bracken Ridge Conveyancing – Bridgeman Downs Conveyancing – Conveyancing –  Brighton Conveyancing – Brisbane Airport Conveyancing – Carseldine Conveyancing – Chermside Conveyancing – Chermside West Conveyancing – Clayfield Conveyancing – Deagon Conveyancing – Eagle Farm Conveyancing  – Everton Park Conveyancing – Ferny Grove Conveyancing – Fitzgibbon Conveyancing – Gaythorne Conveyancing – Geebung Conveyancing – Gordon Park Conveyancing – Grange Conveyancing – Hamilton Conveyancing – Hendra Conveyancing – Kalinga Conveyancing – Kedron Conveyancing – Keperra Conveyancing – Lutwyche Conveyancing – McDowall Conveyancing – Mitchelton Conveyancing – Myrtletown Conveyancing – Newmarket Conveyancing – Northgate Conveyancing – Nudgee Conveyancing – Nudgee Beach Conveyancing – Nundah Conveyancing – Pinkenba Conveyancing – Sandgate Conveyancing – Shorncliffe Conveyancing – Stafford Conveyancing – Stafford Heights Conveyancing – Taigum Conveyancing – Virginia Conveyancing – Wavell Heights Conveyancing – Wilston Conveyancing – Windsor Conveyancing – Wooloowin Conveyancing – Zillmere Conveyancing
Acacia Ridge Conveyancing – Algester Conveyancing – Annerley Conveyancing – Archerfield Conveyancing – Burbank Conveyancing – Calamvale Conveyancing – Coopers Plains Conveyancing– Darra Conveyancing – Doolandella Conveyancing – Drewvale Conveyancing– Durack Conveyancing – Dutton Park Conveyancing – Eight Mile Plains Conveyancing – Ellen Grove Conveyancing – Fairfield Conveyancing – Forest Lake Conveyancing – Greenslopes Conveyancing – Heathwood Conveyancing – Holland Park Conveyancing – Holland Park West Conveyancing – Inala Conveyancing – Karawatha Conveyancing – Kuraby Conveyancing – Larapinta Conveyancing – MacGregor Conveyancing – Mackenzie Conveyancing – Mansfield Conveyancing – Moorooka Conveyancing – Mount Gravatt Conveyancing – Mount Gravatt East Conveyancing – Nathan Conveyancing – Pallara Conveyancing – Parkinson Conveyancing – Richlands Conveyancing – Robertson Conveyancing – Rochedale Conveyancing – Rocklea Conveyancing – Runcorn Conveyancing – Salisbury Conveyancing – Seventeen Mile Rocks Conveyancing – Sinnamon Park Conveyancing – Stones Corner Conveyancing – Stretton Conveyancing – Sumner Conveyancing – Sunnybank Conveyancing – Sunnybank Hills Conveyancing – Tarragindi Conveyancing – Tennyson Conveyancing – Upper Mount Gravatt Conveyancing – Wacol Conveyancing – Willawong Conveyancing – Wishart Conveyancing – Yeerongpilly Conveyancing – Yeronga Conveyancing
Balmoral Conveyancing – Belmont Conveyancing – Bulimba Conveyancing – Camp Hill Conveyancing – Cannon Hill Conveyancing – Carina Conveyancing – Carina Heights Conveyancing – Carindale Conveyancing – Chandler Conveyancing – Coorparoo Conveyancing – Gumdale Conveyancing – Hawthorne Conveyancing – Hemmant Conveyancing – Lota Conveyancing– Lytton Conveyancing – Manly Conveyancing – Manly West Conveyancing – Moreton Island Conveyancing – Morningside Conveyancing – Murarrie Conveyancing – Norman Park Conveyancing – Port of Brisbane Conveyancing – Ransome Conveyancing – Seven Hills Conveyancing – Tingalpa Conveyancing – Wakerley Conveyancing – Wynnum Conveyancing – Wynnum West Conveyancing
Anstead Conveyancing – Ashgrove Conveyancing – Auchenflower Conveyancing – Bardon Conveyancing – Bellbowrie Conveyancing – Brookfield Conveyancing – Chapel Hill Conveyancing – Chelmer Conveyancing – Chuwar Conveyancing – Corinda Conveyancing – Enoggera Conveyancing – Enoggera Reservoir Conveyancing – Fig Tree Pocket Conveyancing – Graceville Conveyancing – Indooroopilly Conveyancing – Jamboree Heights Conveyancing – Jindalee Conveyancing – Karana Downs Conveyancing – Kenmore Conveyancing – Kenmore Hills Conveyancing – Kholo Conveyancing – Lake Manchester Conveyancing – Middle Park Conveyancing – Milton Conveyancing – Moggill Conveyancing – Mount Coot-tha Conveyancing – Mount Crosby Conveyancing – Mount Ommaney Conveyancing – Oxley Conveyancing – Pinjarra Hills Conveyancing – Pullenvale Conveyancing – Riverhills Conveyancing – Seventeen Mile Rocks Conveyancing – Sherwood Conveyancing – Sinnamon Park Conveyancing – St Lucia Conveyancing – Taringa Conveyancing – The Gap Conveyancing – Toowong Conveyancing – Upper Brookfield Conveyancing – Upper Kedron Conveyancing – Westlake Conveyancing
Augustine Heights Conveyancing – Barellan Point Conveyancing – Basin Pocket Conveyancing – Bellbird Park Conveyancing – Blacksoil Conveyancing – Blackstone Conveyancing – Booval Conveyancing – Brassall Conveyancing – Brookwater Conveyancing – Bundamba Conveyancing – Camira Conveyancing – Carole Park Conveyancing – Churchill Conveyancing – Chuwar Conveyancing – Coalfalls Conveyancing – Collingwood Park Conveyancing– Dinmore Conveyancing – East Ipswich Conveyancing – Eastern Heights Conveyancing – Ebbw Vale Conveyancing – Flinders View Conveyancing – Gailes Conveyancing – Goodna Conveyancing – Ipswich Conveyancing – Karalee Conveyancing – Karrabin Conveyancing – Leichhardt Conveyancing – Moores Pocket Conveyancing – Muirlea Conveyancing – New Chum Conveyancing – Newtown Conveyancing – North Booval Conveyancing– North Ipswich Conveyancing – North Tivoli Conveyancing – One Mile Conveyancing – Raceview Conveyancing – Redbank Conveyancing – Redbank Plains Conveyancing – Riverview Conveyancing – Sadliers Crossing Conveyancing – Silkstone Conveyancing – Springfield Conveyancing – Springfield Central Conveyancing – Springfield Lakes Conveyancing – Tivoli Conveyancing – West Ipswich Conveyancing – Woodend Conveyancing – Wulkuraka Conveyancing – Yamanto Conveyancing
Amberley Conveyancing – Ashwell Conveyancing – Calvert Conveyancing – Deebing Heights Conveyancing – Ebenezer Conveyancing – Goolman Conveyancing – Grandchester Conveyancing – Haigslea Conveyancing – Ironbark Conveyancing – Jeebropilly Conveyancing – Lanefield Conveyancing – Marburg Conveyancing – Mount Forbes Conveyancing – Mount MarrowConveyancing – Mutdapilly Conveyancing – Pine Mountain Conveyancing – Purga Conveyancing – Ripley Conveyancing – Rosewood Conveyancing – South Ripley Conveyancing – Spring Mountain Conveyancing – Swanbank Conveyancing – Tallegalla Conveyancing – Thagoona – The Bluff Conveyancing – Walloon Conveyancing – White Rock Conveyancing – Willowbank Conveyancing – Woolshed Conveyancing
Bahrs Scrub Conveyancing – Bannockburn Conveyancing – Beenleigh Conveyancing – Belivah Conveyancing – Berrinba Conveyancing – Bethania Conveyancing – Boronia Heights Conveyancing – Browns Plains Conveyancing – Buccan Conveyancing – Carbrook Conveyancing – Cedar Creek Conveyancing – Cedar Grove Conveyancing – Cedar Vale Conveyancing – Chambers Flat Conveyancing – Cornubia Conveyancing – Crestmead Conveyancing – Daisy Hill Conveyancing – Eagleby Conveyancing – Edens Landing Conveyancing – Forestdale Conveyancing – Greenbank Conveyancing – Heritage Park Conveyancing – Hillcrest Conveyancing – Holmview Conveyancing – Jimboomba Conveyancing – Kagaru Conveyancing – Kingston Conveyancing – Logan Central Conveyancing – Logan Reserve Conveyancing – Logan Village Conveyancing – Loganholme Conveyancing – Loganlea Conveyancing – Lyons Conveyancing – Marsden Conveyancing – Meadowbrook Conveyancing – Mount Warren Park Conveyancing – Mundoolun Conveyancing – Munruben Conveyancing – New Beith Conveyancing – North Maclean Conveyancing – Park Ridge South Conveyancing – Park Ridge Conveyancing – Priestdale Conveyancing – Regents Park Conveyancing – Rochedale South Conveyancing – Shailer Park Conveyancing – Slacks Creek Conveyancing – South Maclean Conveyancing – Springwood Conveyancing – Stockleigh Conveyancing – Tamborine Conveyancing – Tanah Merah Conveyancing – Underwood Conveyancing – Undullah Conveyancing – Veresdale Scrub Conveyancing – Veresdale Conveyancing – Waterford West Conveyancing – Waterford Conveyancing – Windaroo Conveyancing – Wolffdene Conveyancing – Woodhill Conveyancing – Woodridge Conveyancing – Yarrabilba Conveyancing
Alexandra Hills Conveyancing – Amity Point Conveyancing – Birkdale Conveyancing – Capalaba Conveyancing – Cleveland Conveyancing – Coochiemudlo Island Conveyancing – Dunwich Conveyancing – Karragarra Island Conveyancing – Lamb Island Conveyancing – Macleay Island Conveyancing – Mount Cotton Conveyancing – North Stradbroke Island Conveyancing – Ormiston Conveyancing – Point Lookout Conveyancing – Redland Bay Conveyancing – Russell Island Conveyancing – Sheldon Conveyancing – Thorneside Conveyancing – Thornlands Conveyancing – Victoria Point Conveyancing – Wellington Point Conveyancing
Albany Creek Conveyancing – Arana Hills Conveyancing – Banksia Beach Conveyancing – Beachmere Conveyancing – Bellara Conveyancing – Bongaree Conveyancing – Bray Park Conveyancing – Brendale Conveyancing – Bunya Conveyancing – Burpengary Conveyancing – Caboolture Conveyancing – Caboolture South Conveyancing – Cashmere Conveyancing – Clontarf Conveyancing – Dakabin Conveyancing – Deception Bay Conveyancing – Eatons Hill Conveyancing – Elimbah Conveyancing – Everton Hills Conveyancing  – Ferny Hills Conveyancing – Godwin Beach Conveyancing – Griffin Conveyancing – Joyner Conveyancing – Kallangur Conveyancing – Kippa-Ring Conveyancing – Kurwongbah Conveyancing – Lawnton Conveyancing – Mango Hill Conveyancing – Margate Conveyancing – Moodlu Conveyancing – Morayfield Conveyancing – Murrumba Downs Conveyancing – Narangba Conveyancing – Newport Conveyancing – Ningi Conveyancing – North Lakes Conveyancing – Petrie Conveyancing – Redcliffe Conveyancing – Rothwell Conveyancing – Sandstone Point Conveyancing – Scarborough Conveyancing – Strathpine Conveyancing – Upper Caboolture Conveyancing – Warner Conveyancing – Whiteside Conveyancing – Woody Point Conveyancing – Woorim Conveyancing
Armstrong Creek Conveyancing – Bellmere Conveyancing – Bellthorpe Conveyancing – Booroobin Conveyancing – Bracalba Conveyancing – Camp Mountain Conveyancing – Campbells Pocket Conveyancing – Cedar Creek Conveyancing – Cedarton Conveyancing – Clear Mountain Conveyancing – Closeburn Conveyancing – Commissioners Flat Conveyancing – D’Aguilar Conveyancing – Dayboro Conveyancing – Delaneys Creek Conveyancing – Donnybrook Conveyancing – Draper Conveyancing – Highvale Conveyancing – Jollys Lookout Conveyancing – King Scrub Conveyancing – Kobble Creek Conveyancing – Laceys Creek Conveyancing – Meldale Conveyancing – Moorina Conveyancing – Mount Delaney Conveyancing – Mount Glorious Conveyancing – Mount Mee  Conveyancing – Mount Nebo Conveyancing – Mount Pleasant Conveyancing – Mount Samson Conveyancing – Neurum Conveyancing – Ocean View Conveyancing – Rocksberg Conveyancing – Rush Creek Conveyancing – Samford Valley Conveyancing – Samford Village Conveyancing – Samsonvale Conveyancing – Stanmore Conveyancing – Stony Creek Conveyancing – Toorbul Conveyancing – Wamuran Basin Conveyancing – Wamuran Conveyancing – Welsby Conveyancing – White Patch Conveyancing – Wights Mountain Conveyancing – Woodford Conveyancing – Yugar Conveyancing

 

Written by

The author didnt add any Information to his profile yet